Friday, February 02, 2007
Scientists: "Oops, My bad!
A summary of the conclusions are that:
1. Global warming IS taking place at a rapid pace
2. Humans ARE primarily responsible.
3. Warming will continue for 100s of years
4. The effects are goiing to be fewer but more devastating hurricanes, longer and more devasting heat waves, droughts and a rise in sea levels....
There isn't much that can be done at this point but slowing emissions will perhaps slow the effects.....
I talked with a meteorologist today who, like most good scientists, has tried to stay above the political fray and rely on the science to settle the matter. Today, he considered the matter settled. I asked whether he thought that the argument would now be about whether it's actually "worth the effort" to try to mitigate the change. He was very unscientific in his answer but profound nevertheless: "Not doing anything is like saying "See ya in hell!" He's right I think.
But even as the words of the report start to spread around the world, the "deniers" are busy at work. Look at this article from The Guardian. It seems that our favorite right wing "think tank", The American Enterprise Institute, has put out a notice that it will pay $10,000 to any scientist who will contridict today's report. (Olbermann reported on this tonight but the video
isn't up yet) Here's a snippet:
Scientists and economists have been offered $10,000 each by a lobby group funded by one of the world's largest oil companies to undermine a major climate change report due to be published today.
Letters sent by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), an ExxonMobil-funded thinktank with close links to the Bush administration, offered the payments for articles that emphasise the shortcomings of a report from the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).
Later on in the article we find that somewhere around 20 AEI employees have been consultants to the Bush Administration. It doesn't take much of a memory to recall that the AEI is the favorite venue for Bush and Cheney to deliver speeches hyping their policies....that's because the policies were most likely written by the AEI in the first place.
AEI "Fellows" are all over the place. The one who irks me most is CNN's Chief Political Analyst who is sometimes identified (in his credentials) as an AEI Fellow.....that's fair...
The point is, AEI is not an honest broker in any sense. They aren't there to analyze the news, they there to spin the news...
I hope the exposure the Guardian article and Olbermann gave them today makes them less likely to confuse the issue again.
Thursday, February 01, 2007
ROAD TRIP!!
in the meantime:
A sad note: Rest in Peace Molly Ivans....your words spoke both wit and wisdom and I will miss you.
The Rude Pundit sums it up well...
From sad to ....well...just plain stupid...
look at this:
again, TheRudeOne sums it up best:" Somewhere, Orson Welles is giggling his fat ass off."
Wednesday, January 31, 2007
Seeing a mirror within a mirror within a mirror
That is, unless they can find some way of distancing the Republican party from Bush and his disastrous policies....
Surprise.
They're already doing it. But there is more, in fact, much more to it than a simple campaign ploy. Let's start the journed by looking at this from yesterday's Glenn Greenwald at Unclaimed Territory:
snip
This cry of victimization was the principal theme at the so-called "National Review Institute conservative summit" held this weekend, at which one conservative luminary after the next paraded on stage to lament that the unpopular President and rejected GOP-controlled Congress "abandoned" conservatism and failed for that reason.
As usual, Glenn granulate does an excellent analysis of this rather weighty subject. (Let's face it, discussing political philosophy in depth isn't exactly front-page material for newspapers these days because it actually requires "thinking" and as we all know, "thinking" is hard work.)
While Greewald notes that this theme of victimhood is becoming the favorite theme of Republicans today, that one of the early pioneers of Bush-bashing by "real conservatives" was done by none other than Conservative Blogger par exella'nce, Andrew Sullivan. Glenn takes a little excursion into a review of Sullivan's book, The Conservative Soul which eventually brings us to these points:
One of the principal flaws of Sullivan's book is that it speaks of "political conservatism" in a way that exists only in the abstract but never in reality. The fabled Goldwater/Reagan small-government "conservatism of doubt" which Sullivan hails -- like the purified, magnanimous form of Communism -- exists, for better or worse, only in myth.
He goes on here to a phrase which eventually trips a trigger with me:
All of the attributes which have made the Bush presidency so disastrous are not in conflict with political conservatism as it exists in reality. Those attributes -- vast expansions of federal power to implement moralistic agendas and to perpetuate political power, along with authoritarian faith in the Leader -- are not violations of "conservative principles." Those have become the defining attributes of the Conservative Movement in this country.
But conservatives have to perpetuate the myth, so Sullivan critiques the Bush administration in terms of its "infidelity" to "conservative principles" to wit:
Sullivan's general critique of the Bush administration, and his specific complaint that it has fundamentally deviated from the abstract conservative principles to which people like Lowry (columnist and talking-head Rich Lowry)profess fidelity, is both accurate and persuasive. Along those lines, Sullivan cites the borderline-religious belief in tax cuts, depicted not as sound policy but as a moral good, to be pursued "unrelated to any empirical context of consistent rationale," and thus imposed even in the face of suffocating deficits and the virtually unprecedented expansion of government spending.
What seems so strange to me is that Republicans and conservatives in this country still persist in the myth of the principles of the conservative movement. It is the banner under which they rally the troops for each and every election cycle.
But the conservative principles which they profess to represent are a lie.
The real conservative principles the use of the power of government to implement their moralistic and/or religious ideals, the absolute power of their chief executive, unfettered capitalism (bordering on crony capitalism) free market economics. All of those principles would be roundly defeated by the voting populace so they have to tell the noble lie of "conservative principles" to get elected.
Deeply troubling is the concept of the noble lie first proposed by the great Professor of Political Science (and father of present day Neocons) Leo Strauss at the University of Chicago. His disciples included, Wolfowitz, Pearle, Rumsfeld, Cheney and even William Kristol. The so-called noble lie is necessary, because, obviously, if the voters knew the real conservative values, the Republicans would never get elected. Here's what Strauss had to say about "noble lies" (according to Wikipedia ):
Noble lies and deadly truths
Strauss noted that thinkers of the first rank, going back to Plato, had raised the problem of whether good and effective politicians could be completely truthful and still achieve the necessary ends of their society. By implication, Strauss asks his readers to consider whether "noble lies" have any role at all to play in uniting and guiding the polis. Are "myths" needed to give people meaning and purpose and to ensure a stable society? Or can men and women dedicated to relentlessly examining, in Nietzsche's language, those "deadly truths", flourish freely? Thus, is there a limit to the political, and what can be known absolutely? In The City and Man, Strauss discusses the myths outlined in Plato's Republic that are required for all governments. These include a belief that the state's land belongs to it even though it was likely acquired illegitimately, and that citizenship is rooted in something more than the accidents of birth. Strauss has been interpreted as endorsing "noble lies;" myths used by political leaders seeking to maintain a cohesive society. [1] [2] [3]
So the myth of "conservative principles" is still part of the neocon culture and is being played out today in preparation for the rise of another neocon to the Presidency......another "noble lie" so we can be told more "noble lies"
Not if I can help it.....
Tuesday, January 30, 2007
Among other things.....
Fortunately there are enough bloggers out there to keep up with everything and let us "5th tier" (I only claim to be 5th tier because I don't think there's anything lower) bloggers pick and choose what we want to write about.....
I'll start with what I think is the most under-reported story of the day....Bush and his Presidential Executive Orders. The story appeared in this morning's New York Times and here is a snippet to explain it...
In an executive order published last week in the Federal Register, Mr. Bush said that each agency must have a regulatory policy office run by a political appointee, to supervise the development of rules and documents providing guidance to regulated industries. The White House will thus have a gatekeeper in each agency to analyze the costs and the benefits of new rules and to make sure the agencies carry out the president’s priorities.
In case you haven't noticed, that's absolutely breath-taking in its scope....."each agency" will now be controlled by a political appointee as a gatekeeper to carry out the president's priorities....." And we were foolish enough to think that Bush is a lame duck.
Getaclue......
Bush has no intention of being a lame duck. In fact, there have been other blogs reporting that Bush and Company (known in the blogosphere as Bushco) plan on spending the last two years doing the Haagar the Horrible routine on Government....Haagar the Horrible being Rape! Pillage! and Plunder!
He seems to think that he can do this because we can't touch him. We can't impeach and even if we try he can do an awful lot damage (pillage) before we get to him....I'm beginning to think impeachment may be a worthwhile endeavor.
This was under-reported (in my view) because most of the blogosphere has been focusing on the "Scooter" Libby trial. Okay. Scooter's trial is important because it is shinning a light into the dark, dark recesses of the Bush Administration and specifically into the even darker recesses of the heart (alleged heart) of Dick Cheney....
Judith Miller was on the stand today and probably will be tomorrow too. I'll have to go "surfing" to find out where I saw it, but somebody posted today about a couple of radio announcers in Africa who were found guilty in court of murder because their radio broadcasts encited violence against the Tsusti....In a way, that's exactly what Judith Miller did....she encited violence against Iraq by being a willing tool of those who wanted war under any circumstance...truth didn't matter....neither did international law...or christian values (which they claimed to possess.) I've wondered if Judith Miller knew she was being fed bs by top ranked administration officials...I know that she was trading her journalistic integrity for fame
but I have to wonder if she ever once questioned the validity of the information she was being given....he she ever thought to get a second source...a confirmation ...anything that would have lead to the truth? You think?
....and another thing...I caught Keith Olbermann's "Special Comment" tonight. It was about the four examples of "foiled terrorist plots" that Bush took credit for in the SOTU...
Surprise!
They were all phoney!
Crooks and Liars doesn't have it yet but here's a link to the preview
breaking news...MSNBC is reporting that it has gained access to a secret Pentagon report claiming that IRAN was behing the ambush and killing of five American Soldiers last week...
crap....
they've got their f-ing GULF OF TONKIN incident/
I'm really pissed.
Monday, January 29, 2007
If you're not with us (yawn) ...you're (yawn) etc...
When you're getting your annual physical from the Doctor and he takes that funky little hammer with the rummer end shaped like a tomahawk and taps your knee with it, your leg automatically kicks out. If you're blessed not to be physically or neuorologcially damaged, it's a natural response.... a reflex action. Well, our good friends in the Republican Party have developed a couple of verbal reflex actions that we can count upon with the same reliability as the doctor hitting us with that funky little hammer. Truth be told, they're getting a little tiresome and it looks like Glenn Reynolds at Unclaimed Territory is equally tired of hearing at least one of them and does a masterful job of shooting down the talking point du jour of the Republican talking heads.
I think Glenn is particularly miffed that Republicans have been painting themselves as "Churchillian" in this "epic struggle" and Karen Hughes has outright characterized her George W. Bush as such a few times in the post-9/11 world. Glenn does a far better job of documenting it than I and proceeds to tear down the RW talking point with quotes from Churchill AND Abraham Lincoln, actually from CONGRESSMAN Abraham Lincoln.
Churchill and Lincoln share a spot in the American heart for the courage they exhibited during times of great peril to their respective nations. What Greenwald points out so successfully is that they did so not by cutting off debate or (although Lincoln suspended the Chicago Newspaper obstenbibly for publishing military secrets) demanding blind, unquestioning allegiance, but by demanding that debate take place.
Churchill, for example did the most risky thing imaginable in a Parliamentary form of Government: He demanded a debate AND a vote of confidence. As we all know, a vote of "No Confidence" in such a system triggers resignations and new elections. But Churchill demanded it. And even better, in his address demanding that the debate (and subsequent vote) take place, he said this:
Therefore, I feel entitled to come to the House of Commons, whose servant I am . . . I have never ventured to predict the future. I stand by my original programme, blood, toil, tears and sweat, which is all I have ever offered, to which I added, five months later, "many shortcomings, mistakes and disappointments." But it is because I see the light gleaming behind the clouds and broadening on our path, that I make so bold now as to demand a declaration of confidence of the House of Commons as an additional weapon in the armoury of the united nations"
let me repeat myself:
"to which I added, five months later, "many shortcomings, mistakes and disappointments"..."
Churchill dealt with Parliament (House of Commons) in the most honest, straightforward manner he could muster and he won the debate AND the vote.
There is also an interesting quote from Lincoln in there where he criticizes President Polk for taking war powers upon himself. Lincoln refreshes to the logic of the framers of the Constitution in making Congress and not the President responsible for declarations of War. Alberto Gonzales should read it sometime because it makes the argument of the "unitary executive" seem small and weak by comparisom.
Greenwald's summary is priceless...and damning
snip:
The view of America as advocated by George Bush and his followers is as antithetical as can be even to the views of the individuals to whom they claim allegiance. They exploit historical events and iconic individuals as tawdry props, and they neither understand them nor actually care about their meaning. They turn them into cheap cartoons -- Churchill! Lincoln! America! -- drained of their actual substance and converted into impoverished, degraded symbols used to promote ideas that are the exact opposite of what they actually embody.
Churchill accomplished exactly that which Bush cannot manage -- namely, he convinced his country that the war he was leading was legitimate and necessary and that confidence in his war leadership was warranted. It's precisely because Bush is incapable of achieving that that he and his followers are now insisting that democratic debate itself over the Leader and the war is illegitimate and unpatriotic. One can call that many things. "Churchillian" isn't one of them. Nor, for that matter, is "American."
Over on Crooks and Liars there is another message. This one to Sean Hannity from Teddy Roosevelt. It seems Mr Hannity had his "enemy of the State" segment changed to" enemy of the week". It seems that in order to qualify to become an "enemy" of the state/week all you have to do is criticize the President or the Administration. (Are we sensing a theme here?) Here's what that President Teddy Roosevelt had to say:
Teddy Roosevelt in his own words
"[The President] should be supported or opposed exactly to the degree which is warranted by his good conduct or bad conduct, his efficiency or inefficiency in rendering loyal, able, and disinterested service to the Nation as a whole.
Therefore it is absolutely necessary that there should be full liberty to tell the truth about his acts, and this means that it is exactly necessary to blame him when he does wrong as to praise him when he does right. Any other attitude in an American citizen is both base and servile.
To announce that there must be no criticism of the President, or that we are to stand by the President, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public. "
hehehehe......'nuff said.
And finally, we might ask ourselves "what is the danger in "rallying behind" the President in times of great striff or great danger? What, indeed is the danger in presenting a "unified front" to the enemy?"
What indeed?
Click on this link and let the great actor Spencer Tracey tell you.
Sunday, January 28, 2007
Now THAT'S what I'm talking about.....
Finally somebody is posting on what I think the most important issues are concerning Iraq.
I posted on the WoodCoDems site some time ago that maybe we (as a country perhaps but maybe as a Democratic Party) should be talking in terms of WHAT Iraq would/will look like AFTER WE LEAVE. And of course, I mean after we leave under the real circumstances, NOT the NeverLand crap that Bush says will happen if we only give him "one more last chance. "(Yes. Yes, I believe that was the title of a crappy country-western song.)
Let's get to Mimikatz's post before this turns into an uncontrollable rant.... Of course, you're free to click on the link and read the whole article but I'll give a blow-by-blow here.
Mimikatz starts out with the question we're all asking. That is, can the doomsday prophesies of Bush and Cheney about what will happen in Iraq if we pull out be true? I'll have to admit, it's been nagging at me too if, for no other reason, than because there has been such a dirth of information or informed commentary on the likely nature of Iraq after a U.S. withdrawal. But Mimikatz comes up with a couple of sources...The first by General William Odom in his prepared remarks to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee which were aptly entitled:
Anybody want to guess how I really feel about this?
After a lengthy preamble describing how we got into this sorry state, Odom says this:
It cannot as long as fails to revise its war aims. Wise leaders in war have many times admitted that their war aims are misguided and then revised them to deal with realities beyond their control. Such leaders make tactical withdrawals, regroup, and revise their aims, and design new strategies to pursue them. Those who cannot make such adjustments eventually face defeat.
Here's a key point:
Since the 1950's, the US aim in this region has been "regional stability" above all others. The strategy for achieving this aim of every administration until the present one has been maintaining a regional balance of power among three regional forces – Arabs, Israelis, and Iranians.
and finally this:
Any new strategy that does realistically promise to achieve regional stability at a cost we can prudently bear, and does not regain the confidence and support of our allies, is doomed to failure. To date, I have seen no awareness that any political leader in this country has gone beyond tactical proposals to offer a different strategic approach to limiting the damage in a war that is turning out to be the greatest strategic disaster in our history.
Got that now? We need to think in terms other than "Good vs Evil" or "Global War on Terror". We need to think in time-tested, successful REGIONAL DIPLOMACY TERMS.
Now, if you've read the other post you know that I've chosen to emphasize something different than Minikatz. Mini (sorry for the nickname) thought a key of Odom's presentation was that the government needed to be strong enough to tax and in all fairness to Odom, he makes a good case for it but in terms of what US policy should be, I think the above quotes are pretty much "spot-on".
But there's a second source....actaully a SET of sources gathered by today's San Francisco Chronicle.
For a variety of reasons most of the experts don't see much to the "nightmare scenarios" being proffered by Presidnent Bush and Vice-President Cheney. As General Odom surmised, the experts gathered by the Chronicle agree that the likelihood of instability decreasing as opposed to increasing is most likely for the region if the US withdraws its troops. (Again, I ask you to read the posts to get the details)
But there are other scenarios and considerations...take this one for example:
In Iraq, Mueller said, "The most likely scenario, and it's still a fairly bad one, is that the other countries would contain Iraq and there would be a civil war that would gradually work its way out. The idea of it spreading throughout the Middle East and all over the world strikes me as a considerable stretch. Not that it's impossible. But the best analogy would be the long civil war in Lebanon. Other countries meddled in various ways, but they also kept it there, as much as possible
One-by-one the panalists shoot down the "regional conflict" idea and, most importantly, they analyze the possibilities as well as the probabilities that each of the other actors (Iran, Syria, Saudi Arabia and Turkey) would or could get involved in Iraq if we withdraw.
What I think I like best about the Chronicle piece is that quite rightly states that little has been written about the realistic possibilities and options available to us in Iraq. Read this and comment if you like...here or at Woodcodems....
Whoa...wait a minute here....
First, the Great Republican Wurlitzer is in full swing this morning and the talking heads have their talking points down pat....to wit:
A non-binding resolution against escalation EMBOLDENS our enemies...and this beauty from Mitch(I never met a special interest I didn't like) McConnel :
To show his loyalty, Mitch said:
I think everybody knows what the consequences are. The president doesn't have a stronger supporter in the Senate than the person you're looking at, but I repeat, this is the last chance for the Iraqis to step up and demonstrate this government can function," he said. "The message to the Iraqi government could not be more clear."
but if that praise wasn't effusive enough, he had to add:
paraphrased: The War on Terror has been a resounding success. I consider it absolutely amzaing that we haven't been attacked again in five years.
Ahhhh....I love the smell of wingnuttery in the morning....it smells,....STUPID!
Second I found the effusive praise of Joe Biden this morning to be inappropriate. He was being cheered on by some discussion boards for his comment that "dissent doesn't embolden our enemies, our failed policy emboldens our enemies."
on edit: here's the actual quote courtesy of Talking Points Memo
"It's not the American people or the U.S. Congress who are emboldening the enemy. It's the failed policy of this president going to war without a strategy, going to war prematurely."
And to that I have to say:
WHOA! WAIT A MINUTE!